Dennis Deery
I’ve been lucky to virtually attend the wonderful CongRegation conference, hosted in Ireland every fall. It’s a unique conference that requires attendees to produce a blog post, a video, some work of art as their admission fee. While I still hope to attend in person one day, this year I’m going to once again miss it. However, I still love the challenge of producing a piece of writing on the annual theme, which this year is “trust”. My thoughts, jumbled though they may be this time around, are below. I hope everyone that’s able to attend CongRegation has a great time!
Thanks to the latest artificial intelligence tools, it’s never been easier to create fake pictures, fake videos, fake audio recordings - you name it. Less than five minutes with any of these tools and you can generate video of your favorite politician doing heinous acts, or a phone call from a fake loved one begging for money. At the same time, around the world, but especially here in the United States, we’re seeing a new generation of politicians who exhibit a stunning willingness (or eagerness) to tell the most bold-faced lies, evidence be damned. This combination of powerful tools and actors with the lack of moral fiber to use them bodes poorly for the concept of trust.
Back in the good old days™, we lived in small communities and mostly could trust what we could see and experience with our own senses. You might only know 200 people in your entire lifetime, and while certainly people lied and deceived, spending a lifetime together allowed us to build relationships and figure out who we could trust. As communication and transportation technologies improved, the world we experienced became much bigger. We developed new norms and laws, like contracts, to help ensure trust. With technology like the photograph, we began to believe that images we saw must be real, until people like Stalin’s retouchers proved photos to be untrustable. With each new technology, we’ve had to adapt, to learn when trust is warranted and when it’s best withheld.
And through all of this, trust has always been a personal decision. We rely on our own cues, both observed and intuited, to decide if we’re going to trust an image, a political party, a person, or a company. The learning curve is getting steeper and steeper though. We have to work harder to understand the ways our trust can be manipulated and abused. We need to ensure our knowledge and intuition are at the same level of those wishing to misuse our trust.
We’ve reached a place where the tools of deceit may very well be immune to regulation. At the same time we’ve reached a point where we must work together to address issues and solve threats that are literally civilization-scale. This kind of work is going to require us to trust each other. While the tools continue to advance, it’s critical that we as a society develop strong norms around their use. People willing to simply and plainly lie must be made to pay a social price. If you use advanced tools to break the social codes that govern our human relations, you cannot be trusted to fully participate in our society. We will struggle for the next few years because cultural norms develop much more slowly than new technology (how long did it take us to agree on where it’s okay to use mobile phones?). We will need to be judicious in sharing our trust, and willing to be agile enough to adapt when people or institutions prove themselves unworthy of our trust. We may need to spend more time considering the cost of our trust - if I trust now, what is the damage that can be done to things or people I care about? But most importantly, while our world trends towards more online interactions, we should take pains to meet and interact with people in real-time, in person. Develop trust in environments where you know the tools can’t fake it. Build relationships that can support trust. And keep advocating for the importance of trust as we learn to incorporate these new tools into our world.